Kidney Stones: The Water, Diet and Drink Habits That Prevent Them
Anyone who has had a kidney stone remembers the pain, and about half of the advice they get afterwards is wrong — especially 'stop milk and dahi'. Pakistan's heat makes stones more likely because sweat leaves the urine concentrated. Here is what the trials and large studies show about water, calcium, salt, protein, tea and supplements, and what to do in a Lahore summer.
By Taha Raza
Published
Most kidney stones are made of calcium oxalate. They form when urine is concentrated enough for minerals to crystallise, which is why they are more common in hot countries, in summer and in people who sweat a lot and drink too little. Diet can raise or lower the risk, but the single biggest lever is the volume of urine you pass.
How much water should I drink to prevent kidney stones?
Enough to pass at least 2–2.5 litres of urine a day. A 2009 systematic review in European Urology pooled the randomised trials of diet, fluid and supplements in people who had already had a stone. In two trials, drinking more than 2 litres of water a day, or enough fluid to produce more than 2.5 litres of urine, reduced stone recurrence by 61 percent (relative risk 0.39). In the heat of a Lahore summer, or if you work outdoors or train hard, producing that much urine often takes 3 litres of fluid or more. The simplest check is colour: pale yellow urine through the day, including the afternoon. Our hydration guide covers how much to drink in Pakistani heat.
Should I stop milk and dahi if I have kidney stones?
No — cutting calcium can make calcium oxalate stones more likely. In a 2002 trial in the New England Journal of Medicine, 120 men with recurrent calcium oxalate stones and high urine calcium were randomised for five years to either a traditional low-calcium diet (about 400 mg of calcium a day) or a diet with normal calcium (about 1,200 mg) but less animal protein (52 g a day) and less salt (about 3 g a day). Stones came back in 23 of 60 men on the low-calcium diet but only 12 of 60 on the normal-calcium diet — a relative risk of 0.49. Urinary oxalate rose on the low-calcium diet and fell on the other. Calcium in food binds oxalate in the gut so less is absorbed. An earlier large US study of men found that those eating the most dietary calcium had a lower risk of stones (relative risk 0.66 after adjustment).
Which drinks raise or lower kidney stone risk?
| Drink | Change in risk | Desi equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Sugar-sweetened non-cola soda | +33% | Orange and lemon-lime fizzy drinks |
| Sugar-sweetened cola | +23% | Cola |
| Fruit punch | +18% | Sugary sharbat and packaged fruit drinks are similar, but were not studied |
| Caffeinated coffee | −26% | Coffee |
| Decaffeinated coffee | −16% | — |
| Tea | −11% | Doodh patti and green tea, ideally with less sugar |
| Orange juice | −12% | Fresh orange or kinnow juice |
Tea contains some oxalate, yet in this study tea drinkers had fewer stones, not more, probably because tea adds to fluid intake. Sugary drinks went the wrong way. For most stone formers, plain water should be the main drink, with tea and coffee as part of the total.
Do salt and meat cause kidney stones?
They raise the risk. Extra salt increases the calcium the kidneys push into urine, and large amounts of animal protein raise urine calcium and uric acid. In the large US study of men, those eating the most animal protein had a 33 percent higher risk of stones, while higher potassium (from fruit and vegetables) and higher fluid intake were linked with lower risk. That is why the trial diet that worked combined normal calcium with less salt and less meat. In desi terms: go easy on achar, namak-heavy restaurant karahi and salty snacks, and keep meat to a palm-sized portion rather than a plateful of BBQ. Our blood pressure guide shows where hidden salt hides in Pakistani food, and our gout guide covers uric acid stones.
Which foods are high in oxalate?
- Spinach (palak) is one of the richest sources; saag and palak paneer are fine occasionally, but don't eat them daily if you form calcium oxalate stones.
- Nuts, especially almonds, and chocolate contain moderate amounts — keep portions small.
- Eat high-oxalate foods with a calcium source such as dahi, raita or milk so the calcium binds the oxalate in the gut.
- Don't cut out all oxalate foods without a urine test: many are healthy, and the evidence favours fluid, normal calcium and less salt over strict avoidance.
Do vitamin C supplements cause kidney stones?
They seem to raise the risk in men. In a 2013 Swedish study of 23,355 men followed for 11 years, those taking vitamin C supplements had nearly twice the rate of kidney stones as men who took none (relative risk 1.92), and the risk was higher in those who took seven or more tablets a week (2.23). Vitamin C is partly converted to oxalate. Vitamin C from fruit and vegetables was not the concern. If you have had a stone, skip high-dose vitamin C tablets unless your doctor prescribes them.
When is kidney stone pain an emergency?
- Severe pain in the side or back that spreads to the groin, especially with vomiting.
- Pain with fever or shivering — an infected, blocked kidney needs hospital treatment the same day.
- Being unable to pass urine, or passing very little.
- Blood in the urine with pain.
After a first stone, ask your doctor whether the stone can be analysed and whether you need blood and 24-hour urine tests. Knowing the stone type (calcium oxalate, uric acid or another kind) changes the diet advice.
This article is general information, not medical advice. Kidney stones have several types and causes, and people with kidney disease, heart failure or on fluid restrictions need individual advice on how much to drink. See a doctor for diagnosis and treatment.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much water should I drink to prevent kidney stones?
Enough to pass 2–2.5 litres of urine a day, which cut recurrence by 61 percent in trials. In Pakistani summer heat that often means 3 litres of fluid or more; aim for pale urine all day.
Should I avoid milk and dahi if I have kidney stones?
No. In a five-year trial, a normal-calcium diet with less salt and meat halved recurrence compared with a low-calcium diet. Calcium in food binds oxalate in the gut.
Is tea bad for kidney stones?
Not in the evidence. In a study of 194,095 people, tea drinkers had 11 percent fewer stones. Keep the sugar low and drink plenty of water as well.
Does lemon water dissolve kidney stones?
No. Lemon juice contains citrate, which can make urine less likely to form crystals, but it does not dissolve an existing calcium stone. Its main benefit is helping you drink more water.
Can high protein or whey cause kidney stones?
Very high animal protein raises the risk. A moderate protein intake with enough water is fine for most people, but if you have had a stone, ask your doctor what protein target suits you.
Sources
- Fink HA et al. Diet, fluid, or supplements for secondary prevention of nephrolithiasis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials. European Urology, 2009
- Borghi L et al. Comparison of two diets for the prevention of recurrent stones in idiopathic hypercalciuria. New England Journal of Medicine, 2002
- Curhan GC et al. A prospective study of dietary calcium and other nutrients and the risk of symptomatic kidney stones. New England Journal of Medicine, 1993
- Ferraro PM et al. Soda and other beverages and the risk of kidney stones. Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 2013
- Thomas LD et al. Ascorbic acid supplements and kidney stone incidence among men: a prospective study. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2013
More guides
- How Much Water Should You Drink? Hydration and Electrolytes for Training in Pakistani Heat'Eight glasses' is a guess and 'drink as much as you can' is dangerous. Here are the actual numbers — for a desk day, a summer workout and a Ramadan fast — the sweat test, which drinks count, and when salt matters more than water.
- Pre-Workout and BCAAs: Are They Worth Your Money? What Each Ingredient DoesWalk into any supplement shop in Lahore and you'll be offered a tub of pre-workout and a tub of BCAAs, often before anyone asks about your diet. Some of the ingredients work, some barely do, and some are pointless if you eat enough protein. Here is what the research says about each one, the side effects users report, and where your money is better spent.
- Hair Fall After Dieting or Weight Loss: Causes, Tests and What Actually HelpsA few months after losing weight fast, many people notice handfuls of hair in the shower. It is frightening, and it sells a lot of biotin and hair oil. Usually it is a temporary shedding triggered by the diet itself, sometimes made worse by low iron or other deficiencies. Here is what causes it, which tests matter, what doesn't help, and how to lose weight without it.
