Hip Thrust vs Squat: Which Builds Bigger Glutes? What the Studies Show
Social media says the hip thrust is the king of glute exercises; old-school coaches say just squat. Both camps have a study to point to. Here is what the muscle-activity and MRI training studies actually found, why squat depth matters more than most people think, and a simple glute plan for the gym or home.
By Taha Raza
Published
The gluteus maximus is the largest muscle in the body, and the glutes are among the most asked-about muscles by women who train. They extend the hip — the movement at the top of a hip thrust and on the way up from a squat — and they work hardest when the hips are pushed against a heavy load. Different exercises load them at different points, which is where the argument starts.
Which exercise activates the glutes the most?
The hip thrust, in muscle-activity studies. In a 2015 study in the Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 13 trained women performed back squats and barbell hip thrusts with a weight they could lift about 10 times, while electrodes measured muscle activity. The hip thrust produced roughly double the average activity in the upper and lower glutes and in the hamstrings, with no difference in the front of the thigh. Hip thrusts load the glutes hardest at the top, when they are shortened; squats load them hardest at the bottom, when they are stretched.
Do hip thrusts build bigger glutes than squats?
Not clearly. A 2023 trial in Frontiers in Physiology randomised 34 untrained college-aged adults to train either the hip thrust or the back squat, with the same number of sets, for nine weeks. MRI scans before and after showed similar increases in glute size at the lower, middle and upper glutes, with estimates slightly favouring hip thrusts but too variable to call a winner. Squats grew the quadriceps and the adductors (inner thighs) more. Each group gained more strength in the lift it trained — about 14 kg more on the squat for the squat group and 26 kg more on the hip thrust for the hip thrust group — and deadlift strength improved by the same amount. Higher muscle activity in the first session did not reliably predict who grew more.
| Study | Who | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Contreras 2015, J Appl Biomech | 13 trained women, one session | Hip thrust: about twice the glute activity of the squat |
| Plotkin 2023, Front Physiol | 34 untrained adults, 9 weeks | Similar glute growth on MRI; squats grew quads and inner thighs more |
| Kubo 2019, Eur J Appl Physiol | 17 men, 10 weeks | Full squats grew glutes 6.7% vs 2.2% for half squats |
How deep should you squat for glutes?
Deep. In a 2019 trial in the European Journal of Applied Physiology, 17 men trained either full squats or half squats twice a week for 10 weeks, and MRI measured muscle volume. Both groups grew the front of the thigh similarly (about 5 percent), but the full squat group grew the gluteus maximus by 6.7 percent against 2.2 percent, and the adductors by 6.2 against 2.7 percent. The glutes are stretched most at the bottom of a deep squat, which appears to be where much of the growth stimulus comes from. If your hips or knees allow it, squat until your thighs are at least parallel to the floor; a goblet squat makes depth easier to learn.
What are the best glute exercises?
| Exercise | Where | Why use it |
|---|---|---|
| Barbell or dumbbell hip thrust | Gym or home with a bench or sofa | Heavy glute loading with little knee stress |
| Back squat or goblet squat, full depth | Gym or home with a dumbbell | Glutes, quads and inner thighs together |
| Romanian deadlift | Gym or home with dumbbells | Glutes and hamstrings in a stretched position |
| Bulgarian split squat | Gym or home with a chair | Deep glute stretch, one leg at a time |
| Walking lunges | Anywhere | Glutes and quads; good finisher |
| Glute bridge and single-leg hip thrust | Home, no equipment | Bodyweight option that can still be taken close to failure |
| Band or cable hip abduction | Gym or home with a band | Upper glutes (gluteus medius) for the side of the hips |
A simple twice-weekly glute plan
- 1Day A: full-depth squat 3 × 6–10, hip thrust 3 × 8–12, Romanian deadlift 3 × 8–10, band hip abduction 2 × 15–20.
- 2Day B: Bulgarian split squat 3 × 8–12 each leg, single-leg hip thrust or glute bridge 3 × 12–15, walking lunges 2 × 10 each leg, back extension 2 × 12.
- 3Rest 1–2 minutes between sets and finish each set one to three reps short of failure.
- 4Add weight or reps each week when you hit the top of the rep range — see our progressive overload guide.
- 5Keep upper-body and other training on the remaining days; our best workout split guide shows how.
That plan gives the glutes roughly 10–20 hard sets a week, the range our guide to how many sets per week covers. At home, slow the reps down and use single-leg versions so bodyweight stays challenging.
Why aren't my glutes growing?
- The weights or reps haven't gone up in weeks — progression is what drives growth.
- Sets end far from failure, or you are doing only bodyweight bridges with 30 easy reps.
- Squats stop well above parallel, so the glutes are never fully stretched.
- You are in a steep calorie deficit or eating too little protein; muscle grows slowly when dieting hard.
- You expect glute exercises to burn fat on the hips. Spot reduction doesn't work; overall fat loss reveals the shape.
This article is general information, not medical advice. If you have hip, knee or lower back pain, or have had surgery, check with your doctor or physiotherapist before loading these exercises, and stop any movement that causes sharp pain.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are hip thrusts or squats better for glutes?
Hip thrusts activate the glutes more, but a nine-week MRI trial found similar glute growth from both. Squats also build the thighs. Most people do best with both.
Do squats make your thighs bigger?
Somewhat. In the 2023 trial, squats grew the quadriceps and inner thighs more than hip thrusts did. If you want glute growth with less thigh growth, lean more on hip thrusts and Romanian deadlifts.
How often should I train glutes?
Two or three times a week, with roughly 10–20 hard sets in total, works well for most people. Add weight or reps over time.
Can I grow my glutes at home without weights?
Yes, with single-leg hip thrusts, Bulgarian split squats, deep bodyweight squats and lunges taken close to failure. A pair of dumbbells or a band makes progress easier.
Is half squatting enough for glutes?
Not ideal. In a 10-week trial, full squats grew the gluteus maximus by 6.7 percent versus 2.2 percent for half squats. Squat to at least parallel if your joints allow.
Sources
- Contreras B et al. A comparison of gluteus maximus, biceps femoris, and vastus lateralis electromyographic activity in the back squat and barbell hip thrust exercises. Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 2015
- Plotkin DL et al. Hip thrust and back squat training elicit similar gluteus muscle hypertrophy and transfer similarly to the deadlift. Frontiers in Physiology, 2023
- Kubo K et al. Effects of squat training with different depths on lower limb muscle volumes. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2019
More guides
- Strength Training for Women: Why You Will Not Get BulkyThe fear of getting bulky keeps more women out of strength training than anything else. The physiology says it is not going to happen.
- Calisthenics vs Weights: Can Bodyweight Training Build as Much Muscle as the Gym?No gym membership, a pull-up bar on the door and a roof to train on — can that really build a muscular body? The trials say mostly yes, with two catches: progression and legs. Here is what the research found, how to make bodyweight exercises harder every week, and a three-day home plan.
- Progressive Overload: How to Keep Getting Stronger Every Week, With a Simple Plan to CopyMost people in the gym look the same after a year because they lift the same dumbbells for the same 3 × 10 every week. Progressive overload is the fix — here is the simplest way to do it, how much to add, what the trials say about reps versus weight, and what to do when you stall.
