Skip to content
GymFinity — Fitness & Beyond
Nutrition7 min read

Does Fruit Make You Fat? Mangoes, Bananas, Dates and Fruit Sugar

Mango season arrives and someone at the table says fruit is 'full of sugar' and will make you fat. Others eat three mangoes after dinner because fruit is 'healthy'. Both are half right. Here is what the large studies show about fruit, weight and diabetes, the calories in the fruits Pakistanis actually eat, and how to fit them into a fat-loss plan.

By

Published

Fruit gets blamed and praised for the same reason: it contains sugar. What matters for your waistline is how much energy a portion carries and what it replaces. A whole fruit comes with water and fibre, takes time to eat and fills you up. Blend it into a shake with milk and sugar, or press it into juice, and the same fruit becomes something you can drink in a minute.

Does eating fruit make you gain weight?

No — in the largest studies, people who ate more fruit gained less weight. A 2015 analysis in PLOS Medicine followed 133,468 American men and women in three long-running cohorts from 1986 to 2010, looking at how changes in what they ate over each four-year period related to changes in weight, after adjusting for exercise, smoking and the rest of the diet. Every extra daily serving of fruit was linked with 0.53 lb (0.24 kg) less weight gain over four years. Berries (−1.11 lb per daily serving) and apples and pears (−1.24 lb) had the strongest links. Starchy vegetables such as potatoes went the other way. These are observational findings, so they show association, not proof — but they are the opposite of 'fruit makes you fat'.

How many calories are in mango, banana and dates?

Calories in common fruits and fruit drinks (values from the GymFinity app's food table; shakes and fresh juice are estimates)
FoodPortionCaloriesCarbs
Mango (aam)1 medium, about 200 g flesh12030 g
Banana (kela)1 medium10527 g
Apple (saib)1 medium9525 g
Orange or kinnow1 medium6015 g
Dates (khajoor)3 dates7018 g
Fresh orange juice1 glass (300 ml)13531 g
Packaged fruit juice1 glass (250 ml)11528 g
Mango shake with sugar1 glass (350 ml)33055 g
Banana shake with sugar1 glass (350 ml)30048 g
Gulab jamun, for comparison1 piece15022 g

A mango is not the problem; three mangoes after dinner every night of the season is 360 kcal, about the same as a glass of mango shake. One medium fruit is a snack-sized portion of calories. A shake or a large glass of juice is closer to a small meal.

Is the sugar in fruit bad for you?

Not in whole fruit. The WHO's 2015 sugar guideline limits 'free sugars' — sugar added to food and drink, plus the sugars in honey, syrups and fruit juice — but it does not count the sugar inside whole fruit, because it comes packaged with fibre and water and there is no evidence that it causes harm. That is why fruit juice is treated differently from the fruit it was made from. Our guide to how much sugar per day explains the limit and where most Pakistanis actually get their sugar: tea.

Can diabetics eat mango, banana and dates?

Usually yes, in measured portions. A 2013 BMJ analysis of 187,382 people in the same US cohorts found that eating more whole fruit was linked with slightly lower type 2 diabetes risk (hazard ratio 0.98 for every three servings a week), with blueberries, grapes and apples showing the strongest links and bananas also slightly protective (0.95). Fruit juice was linked with higher risk: 1.08 for every three glasses a week. Most whole fruits have a low or medium glycaemic index — about 51 for mango, 51–60 for banana depending on ripeness and 42 for dates (see our glycaemic index guide) — but portion size still decides the blood sugar rise.

  • Count fruit as part of your carbohydrate for the day: one medium mango has about 30 g, a little less than one and a half rotis.
  • Eat one portion at a time, ideally with or after a meal, or with protein such as dahi or a handful of nuts.
  • Choose whole fruit over juice and shakes.
  • Check your glucose meter two hours after a new fruit if you have diabetes, and follow your doctor's or dietitian's plan.

Will eating more fruit help me lose weight?

Only if it replaces something. A 2014 meta-analysis in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition looked at randomised trials that told people to eat more fruit and vegetables, or delivered them to their homes, without asking them to cut anything else. Weight did not change. The authors concluded that 'eat more fruit' only helps with weight when it comes with eating less of other energy sources. The useful swap is fruit instead of biscuits, mithai or a second paratha — not fruit on top of them.

How much fruit should I eat a day?

The WHO advises at least 400 g of fruit and vegetables a day — roughly five portions. For most people that means two or three portions of fruit plus vegetables at lunch and dinner. A portion is one medium fruit, a cup of chopped fruit or three dates.

  • Eat fruit whole; save shakes and fresh juice for occasional treats.
  • In mango season, treat one mango as your daily sweet or snack rather than an extra.
  • Break your fast with three dates in Ramadan — about 70 kcal — rather than a plateful.
  • Fruit chaat is fine; skip the added sugar and cream.
  • Keep a bowl of fruit where the biscuit tin used to be.

This article is general information, not medical advice. If you have diabetes, kidney disease or another medical condition, or take medicines that affect blood sugar or potassium, ask your doctor or dietitian how much fruit suits you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does fruit make you fat?

No. In a study of 133,468 people, each extra daily serving of fruit was linked with less weight gain over four years. Weight gain comes from total calories, and whole fruit is filling for its calories.

Is mango fattening?

One medium mango is about 120 kcal, less than one gulab jamun. Mango only becomes a problem in large amounts or as a sugary shake, which is about 330 kcal a glass.

Is banana good for weight loss?

A medium banana is about 105 kcal and fits easily into a fat-loss diet, especially as a snack in place of biscuits. It won't cause weight loss on its own; your overall calorie intake does.

How many dates can I eat a day?

Three dates are about 70 kcal and 18 g of carbohydrate, which suits most people. Dates are dense in sugar, so a handful adds up quickly.

Is fruit juice as healthy as whole fruit?

No. Juice loses the fibre and is easy to drink in large amounts. In large US cohorts, whole fruit was linked with lower type 2 diabetes risk and fruit juice with higher risk.

Sources

  1. Bertoia ML et al. Changes in intake of fruits and vegetables and weight change in United States men and women followed for up to 24 years: analysis from three prospective cohort studies. PLOS Medicine, 2015
  2. Muraki I et al. Fruit consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes: results from three prospective longitudinal cohort studies. BMJ, 2013
  3. Kaiser KA et al. Increased fruit and vegetable intake has no discernible effect on weight loss: a systematic review and meta-analysis. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2014
  4. World Health Organization. Guideline: sugars intake for adults and children. 2015
WhatsAppCall Now